The Ninth Commandment: Why Lie?

   Thou Shalt Not Bear False Witness Against Thy Neighbor-Exodus 20:16

   Men lie for various good causes. In fact, men seldom lie for bad ones. The bad causes take care of themselves. A man may lie for a good cause and keep his conscience.

   Men lie out of self-interest.

   The fellow who preceded me as Interim Pastor of the place I now serve became worried about his own future, I think, when he heard I might be called as pastor. He made his living as in interim, had no other place to go at the time and needed to do what he might to prolong his service. He acted in his own better interests, which often makes for torturous logic but can finally be explained by the simplest reason for lying; he needed to do it to take care of himself.

   He shared many "concerns" with the search team. They grew weary of his attacks. Once fearful, now frantic, he took his "concerns" to church members. Cloaked in the kind of spiritual "wariness" that marks the mendacious incompetent, he offered contradictory explanations of his worries from person to person. Naturally he overstepped himself and people saw through him.

   Finally,  a leader took him aside and told him, not uncertainly, to stop his gossip. The craven cave when the light hits them.

   Let me not leave this unsaid. When considering even a temporary shepherd, one must consider the worth of the man before we regard the path. An unkind man will take you to a hurtful place. A greedy man will shear the lambs for his own good. A liar will operate in his own best interests to the detriment of the whole. Evil is evil even if it is only part time.

   Men lie to make themselves larger in story than they are in life.

   The falsified resume is the logical end of the story of "how it might have been." The falsifier counts on the carelessness of his fellows. He hopes no one will check what he says.

   Darkness needs an absence of light to be darkness.

   The end of the falsifier is the "follow up question."

   Men lie to defend their motives.

   Perhaps "defend" is the wrong word. "Obscure" might be more appropriate.

   Men lie to obscure their motives. They might wish to play to a certain crowd. The fellow I have already mentioned in this post, my immediate predecessor, albeit temporary, noted my criticisms of certain denominational practices. He adroitly maneuvered himself between me and the denomination, with himself as the hero of the piece. Soon he was not working part time for the denomination any longer but was full-time!

   The fellow who lies to obscure his ends remembers his scandals as triumphs. He lies first to others and only after to himself. No matter, a liar is still a liar. He erodes the position of all who embrace him.

   A man lies to gain allies when he is too weak to stand on his own. He lacks that inner moral compass that would tell him it is better to be alone than to be bad company.

   Jonathan, whom we have mentioned as the most remarkable man of his time, ill-fated and unlucky, was unacceptable as leader to both the men he served, Saul and David. Jonathan, while never allowed to lead more than an army of one, proved worthwhile as a mediator between the two warring factions because he was both honest and kind.

   Mendicant or mediator? Jonathan kept one man from murder and another from death. He did so by earnest pleading. Saul and David are historical examples of what happens when mendicants come to position. The innocent suffer and the many are more poorly led than they might want. The nation suffered as soon as Jonathan died, just as the masses suffer when the decent, the honest, the noble and the admirable are pushed aside, their bodies broken and their places taken by the salary seeker.

   Men may lie because they are weak and lying is how weakness reacts to strength.

   The thief steals for the thrill of gaining something of worth without the strain of toil. The liar lies in the face of strength for the sake of appearing strong without the exertion of character building. A thief works better in the dark or when valuables are left unguarded. A liar works best when unexamined.

   In the end a thief is still a thief and a liar is a liar. The people who promote and protect them lie down with dogs. They get up with fleas.







3 thoughts on “The Ninth Commandment: Why Lie?”

  1. WOW! This is a remarkable story. It totally blows my mind to think that someone would go to such great lniks to keep a church / ministry related job. I am sorry you had to go thru something like this. It says a lot about your church and the Search Committe that they saw thru the sham of it all.
    Did this person not understand what they were doing to another human being, a fellow minister, a man called of God? Or did they not care? I guess it is a good lesson that reminds us that what we do and the decisions we make do affect others and often in very dramatic ways.
    How did the story end? What became of this person? Where is he now? Is he an Interim Pastor at another church? You may not want to say on a blog… if not I understand. But, since I do not know who you are referring to, I do not know where he is now or what he is doing.

  2. He now works full-time for the BGCT, in addition to he interim work. This is another reason I will not be attending their meetings nor worrying about their support much.
    I do not think he cared about the church or about me. I believe his actions were completely selfish; he wanted to be a hero to those who do not care for my views and he wanted to prolong his paycheck. I hold him in rather complete contempt.
    An interim period can be very helpful for a church but any interim ministry is only as strong as the person you get. We will be some time digging out from under this fellow’s scandal-mongering. He will go on his way, I am sure, to repeat his works at other churches against other pastors. It is a pity.
    I don’t mind commenting openly on this matter on my own blog. I don’t feel obligated to protect secrecy for these people. They have run rough shod for too long. Men like him depend on being able to operate in the dark.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.